Show HN: Don't let your billion-dollar ideas die

(ideaharbor.xyz)

171 points | by curiousmindset2 weeks ago

55 comments

  • ryukoposting2 weeks ago
    > A bidding market and app where beggars can bid for the most prime corners and intersections.

    > A non-cancerous company review board (f glassdoor)

    > Augmented-reality underwear

    Good to know the internet is functioning as usual.

    • K0balt2 weeks ago
      For the bidding market, they will have to displace the existing cartels first. No kidding, these are often controlled by a superhobo, (in my hometown he now owns a house and a nice Tahoe) who “owns” all of the good corners in town. Idk what his take is, but by providing “protection” to corner operators, he seems to do quite well.

      Still, Uber Hobo is still a great idea, you could overwhelm those small operators with flash mobs of hobos during the rollout phase and also accept in app payments so that UH could be assured its 35 percent. Also, as a value add, a BLE beacon that shows you already gave today and to not excessively harass you.

      • devsda2 weeks ago
        > For the bidding market, they will have to displace the existing cartels first. No kidding, these are often controlled by a superhobo, (in my hometown he now owns a house and a nice Tahoe) who “owns” all of the good corners in town. Idk what his take is, but by providing “protection” to corner operators, he seems to do quite well.

        Good to know that some things remain the same regardless of whether it is a developed, developing or a poor country.

      • gs172 weeks ago
        > Also, as a value add, a BLE beacon that shows you already gave today and to not excessively harass you.

        That sounds more like it would quickly become the "sucker" beacon that tells them you pay out.

      • jrflowers2 weeks ago
        > No kidding, these are often controlled by a superhobo

        Counterpoint: This is made up. It is like a crossover episode between HN and AO3

        • K0balt2 weeks ago
          Well, it’s not made upon my hometown, and in the few other places I have talked to Hobos and panhandlers, there seems to be something similar in many places. Btw, some panhandlers do quite well. I met a guy back in the 00s that did web design in the early morning at the coffee shop I used to frequent, and in the afternoon he panhandled. He paid $50(us) a day for “his” corner, sat down there in torn up army surplus gear and a rusty propane tank, and his scruffy looking dog, with a sign that said “need money for gas and beer”. He told me that his nightly rake was between 100 and 300 after his “rent”.

          I still don’t know which was his side hustle.

          • jrflowers2 weeks ago
            There is literally no such thing as a superhobo, that is a complete fabrication.

            The ocean of difference between “I’ve heard of some folks getting shook down” and “If you see someone panhandling they are likely part of an organized network” is incredibly vast. It is to take one small observation and extrapolate it into a pure fantasy. It is quite literally made up. It kind of sounds like you were told and then credulously believed an urban legend.

            Source: Have been homeless, panhandled, and decades of work in homeless outreach. I have worked with folks in day shelters, night shelters, street corners, large encampments, etc. for many, many years and what you have written is patently untrue.

            • K0balt2 weeks ago
              Ok, well, maybe it’s different from where you have been. But I’m pretty sure there is no global conspiracy to make me believe this, and it has been directly explained to me by people that were in the life, so to speak.

              Of course, the term “superhobo” is a farcical literary confabulation, I’m sure nobody actually calls them “superhobos”

              My exposure comes from Fairbanks in the 00s, Santo Domingo, Delhi, someplace in California near LA can’t remember. Figured it must be common?

    • bigfatkitten1 week ago
      > A non-cancerous company review board (f glassdoor)

      We used to have one of those.

      https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fucked_Company

    • 2 weeks ago
      undefined
    • haliskerbas2 weeks ago
      Half of these are a16z's next 10x idea. /s
      • justin662 weeks ago
        There’re going to put augmented reality underwear on the blockchain.
        • ozim1 week ago
          I am all into micropayments for peeing.

          With GPS tracking if someone pees in the bushes they will get additional charges.

  • jsheard2 weeks ago
    > Nuclear Landmines

    You underestimate how stupid Cold War weapon projects got, they were putting nukes in anything.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_demolition_munition

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Peacock

    • jamesfinlayson2 weeks ago
      Bat bombs (bombs full of bats with time-delayed releases of napalm) were developed in World War II.
      • philipkglass2 weeks ago
        Documented in Harvard professor Louis Fieser's autobiographical The Scientific Method: A Personal Account of Unusual Projects in War and in Peace

        https://library.sciencemadness.org/library/books/the_scienti...

        https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Louis_Fieser

        • internet_points2 weeks ago

              > The carrying power of a 10-11 gram
              > bat is indeed amazing, some 15-18 grams; the incendiary bomb was in this
              > range (17.5 grams). Bats can carry such loads for miles. And bats with
              > dummy bombs released in housed areas dragged the loads into sites highly
              > favorable for fire-starting. W e released bats successfully at various altitudes
              > both from the B-2 S and from an open Attack Bomber, in which flying was
              > great fun. 
          
          omg

              > Then,
              > suddenly, X-ray was cancelled. I never learned the reason, but can make a
              > guess. The bats would be vectors for bombs, but they would be vectors also
              > for germs. Our side might be accused of initiating biological warfare. 
          
          oh yeah because being accused of doing something horrible while doing something horrible would be horrible.
          • HenryBemis1 week ago
            I believe that they perceived it in the numbers. Exploding bombs will kill a limited number of people. Imagine the nightmare scenario that a bat-bomb will explode in a school and kill 10? 20? toddlers. Now imagine some virus that can wipe hundreds/thousands. This escalation would force the opponent's hand to respond appropriately, and if 'standard' war (bullets, artillery shells, missiles) is hell, chemical warfare is worse.
      • zamalek2 weeks ago
        This only sounds like a ridiculous idea. The weapon was ridiculously effective during an unintentional test.
    • jcgrillo2 weeks ago
      The Russians are working on their very own Project Pluto: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/9M730_Burevestnik
    • Rendello2 weeks ago
      > Chicken-powered nuclear bomb

      Now that's an interesting section (second link)

      • gherard55552 weeks ago
        >A technical problem is that during winter, the temperature of buried devices can drop quickly, creating a possibility that the mechanisms of the mine will cease working due to low temperatures in the winter.[5] Various methods were studied to solve this problem, such as wrapping the bombs in insulating blankets.

        One proposal suggested that live chickens would be sealed inside the casing, with a supply of food and water.[6] They would remain alive for approximately a week. Their body heat would apparently have been sufficient to keep the mine's components at a working temperature.

    • ethbr12 weeks ago
      I mean, if you need to apply 10+ tons of TNT-equivalent to a target, it's a heck of a lot easier to carry. (Also literally, SADM)
  • grensley2 weeks ago
    > Batteries that can store the internet in them for when your connection goes down.

    This is now my favorite way to explain caching.

  • pockmarked192 weeks ago
    A note from Jobs on why just having an idea doesn't work:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7kZ0zoDYOmM

    Doesn't mean ideas aren't valuable, but the process is just as, if not more, important.

    The full interview has more.

    • curiousmindset2 weeks ago
      great idea without execution <<< idea with great execution < great idea with great execution
      • conductr2 weeks ago
        Often great execution = basic execution + luck
  • kylecazar2 weeks ago
    "start podcast that is only ads"

    Brilliant

    • xnx2 weeks ago
      This would be super useful as a training set for automatically identifying ads in podcasts that contain non-ad content.
      • staticautomatic2 weeks ago
        If you produced the podcast this would be trivial since you’d know the time stamps for the ad holes.
        • xnx2 weeks ago
          Yes, though I don't think you know how long the ad block will be. I've seen some podcast MP3 files that have the ad spots indicated in the ID3 tag, but that's not super useful because it only gives the original start points.
        • numpad02 weeks ago
          It'll penalize advertiser provided scripts more.
    • dogboat1 week ago
      QVC!
  • hiccuphippo2 weeks ago
    Pro-tip: add an embarrassing story of yourself to force you to work on the idea before it expires (you can prevent an idea from expiring, right?)
  • ramonverse2 weeks ago
    Hi are the ideas supposed to be anonymous? because you are leaking everyone's names, just by opening network tab.
    • curiousmindset2 weeks ago
      Hey, i didn't decide on this yet. Initially i added the author names on the card so people can see who the idea came from and authors possibly get a little bit of credit.

      But then i thought maybe some people are too shy to give their name away so it's best to remove them.

      I was still in dilemma, so removed it from the UI but not from the api reponses ( will do it now )

      In future, i'll just add an option in the profile, so you can choose to show your name if you want to

      • lolinder2 weeks ago
        For future reference you definitely want to remove PII from the API as soon as it's not needed on the frontend—people, even engineers, naturally expect to be able to visually confirm what information is and isn't public, and you don't want to be that site that exposed data through a side channel.
    • laurent_du2 weeks ago
      Pretty sure it's not the real pg who suggested "Venmo for dogs".
  • frankus2 weeks ago
    An earlier effort along similar lines can be seen at https://www.halfbakery.com
  • ThatCreeper2 weeks ago
    The frontend here only shows the 20 most recently published ideas which is arguably tragic as the other ones are still quite fun to read:

    > Instead of just fries, let customers split their side order between different options (half fries, half onion rings) for the same price

    > lawn sprinklers, but targeted with Ring

    > Venmo for dogs

    > website where you can pay people you know to shut up

    I made an scrollable view here if anyone wants that

    https://thatcreeper.github.io/IdeaWarehouse/

  • sgjohnson2 weeks ago
    > 3. After expiry, the ideas goes public. So if you don't work on them, someone else probably will

    Heh, “someone else probably will” is such a strange way to say “no-one ever will” :D

    • conductr2 weeks ago
      Right, trying to throw off all the competition you’re sure to see with your new “Ad service that shaves company logos into stray cats” service
  • hi_hi2 weeks ago
    This is the HN equivalent of Boaty McBoatface. I love it.
  • hdjY282 weeks ago
    > gay porn

    I think someone already came up with this

    > uber for blowjob

    Limited only to certain geos where prostitution is legal; already exists in certain countries in some shape or form

    • ryukoposting2 weeks ago
      > uber for blowjob

      Pretty sure that's just Snapchat.

  • Uptrenda2 weeks ago
    >Batteries that can store the internet in them for when your connection goes down.

    This idea is kind of great though. Remember that mcmaster car website? One reason it was so fast is it would silently download the next pages before you visited them. Creating the impression of instant loading. Could we do something similar where a program constantly downloaded websites you were most likely to visit in the background? Eventually having both a mass archive of useful content over time and creating the impression that the web were instant? With how cheap storage space now is and how fast connections are maybe the bottleneck now is efficiency of user input.

    • 1 week ago
      undefined
  • joshuaturner2 weeks ago
    > Put hawk tuah in fortnite

    some ideas deserve to die

    • spacebanana72 weeks ago
      It’s hard to see that idea making less than a million dollars if implemented to be fair.
      • stavros2 weeks ago
        It can be an entire franchise, hawk tuah children's books, baby clothes, etc.
    • aio22 weeks ago
      its a w idea
  • jedberg2 weeks ago
    People are messing with it, but I really like the idea. I put my real idea there. It's one I really like but I just don't have the time or expertise to execute it. I really hope someone "steals" it.
    • curiousmindset2 weeks ago
      thanks and glad you liked it :)

      that's actually one of the main "idea" behind the website

  • grensley2 weeks ago
    This site is basically the Target to 4chan's Walmart.
    • spaceflunky1 week ago
      lol

      just a lot less (overt) slurs and slightly more intelligible formatting

  • henning2 weeks ago
    Anyone else working on a mat with conclusions that you can jump to? Mine is going to integrate with AI. Somehow.
    • Kon-Peki2 weeks ago
      I made a prototype, but then I got hit by a truck. So maybe once the settlement comes in.
  • egypturnash2 weeks ago
    This is like highdeas without the charm.
  • hdjY282 weeks ago
    > A battery powered and an LLM-powered sexdoll that talks like a real person and performs inference on-device without making requests to the server for privacy preservation

    I’d invest in this

  • igetspam2 weeks ago
    > An AI-enabled juicer that squeezes single-serve bags of pre-juiced juices

    This is why juicero failed! No AI!

  • dgunay2 weeks ago
    > Breakfast tapas

    I wish you could comment on some of these or vote them "already implemented," because whoever wrote that needs to try Turkish breakfast.

  • airstrike2 weeks ago
    I love how this has both "An antacid pill that you take once every six weeks." and "An antacid that you only take once a week."

    It would be nice to be able to "like" the best ideas. Maybe show "hot" ideas in one column and a random sample on another column? This way readers get what's most relevant while preserving discoverability.

    • left-struck2 weeks ago
      > It would be nice to be able to "like" the best ideas. That’s basically r/ideas
      • airstrike2 weeks ago
        Not at all. Upvotes/likes would essentially be the only common feature between the two.
  • bambax2 weeks ago
    This is excellent. Some features to add (maybe):

    - voting

    - tagging / filtering / sorting

    - commenting? some way to let people meet around an idea?

    Is there some sort of moderation currently?

    • curiousmindset2 weeks ago
      hey thanks !

      just added voting feature, will add the rest as well

      currently there is no moderation, i just made this as a fun project and didn't expect it to go this wild lol. will add it now

  • ilaksh2 weeks ago
    Can you add markdown support? I already submitted one with markdown (username 'runvnc') .. also maybe deal with longer entries like only show the first 250 characters in the box and the rest in a tooltip/hover or when you click up to 1000 characters or something. And then when you click you see the full idea and their contact info.
    • 2 weeks ago
      undefined
    • curiousmindset2 weeks ago
      sure, will add it today.

      thanks for the tooltip idea ! I added the basic "Read more" truncation but it was looking ugly so removed it. Tooltip sounds better

  • lbj2 weeks ago
    > "Release a gorilla wearing a human costume at the gorilla costume contest"

    Absolutely brilliant, 2 billion $ idea at least :)

  • azhenley2 weeks ago
    Similar premise to my blog post: Take my app ideas (https://austinhenley.com/blog/takemyappideas.html)
    • acosmism2 weeks ago
      since you put this out in the world... i might try one
  • thrance2 weeks ago
    Ideas are a dime a dozen, execution is key.
    • Clubber2 weeks ago
      This, and not only the development of the product, but marketing, distribution, payments, accounting, legal, etc.

      I can't count the number of times someone came to me with an idea, suggesting I would do all the work, and we would split it 50/50. "What are you going to do?" "I had the idea." No thanks.

      The funniest is when they want me to sign some sort of NDA. Nah.

    • curiousmindset2 weeks ago
      I 100% agree and believe the same.

      Execution is 99%, and the idea is just 1%. But you still need that 1% to start in the first place.

      The site is just there to help you achieve that 1%.

      In the end, the execution is on to you :)

  • neongreen2 weeks ago
    I started a `#shitty-server-suggestions` channel in one of the Discords I'm in and it's my favorite type of channel. Now we have the same thing online! I'm genuinely happy
  • luxuryballs2 weeks ago
    0. an app where public ideas don’t require a login so I could have posted idea #1

    1. an app where you can point to a body and it will show on the TV so the person behind you knows where to massage

  • j452 weeks ago
    Neat idea - there's so many ideas for anyone to be able to get to that this is a great way to share with people who want to try to build a product instead of a project.

    One thing to learn about is the timing of ideas and when the market is ready for it.

    Also important is learning to build the small ideas that become big ideas.

    • curiousmindset2 weeks ago
      Thank you and that was indeed the idea behind this !

      Also agree that sometimes solving a small, specific problem is what grows into something bigger.

      • j452 weeks ago
        Agree - many big solutions are often a lot of smaller bottlenecks and problems being solved together.
  • mouse_2 weeks ago
    I really love this so much, and can see myself coming back to this page for years. would love to see a replies feature, and top/trending/controversial ideas section etc.

    THANK YOU SO MUCH OP! GREAT IDEA!!

    • curiousmindset2 weeks ago
      heyy, thanks, it means a lot !

      will add each and every feature you requested by this week.

  • brandoniscool1 week ago
    GREAT example of a Minimum Viable Product. Can't wait to see how this evolves. The devs definitely know what they're doing.
  • ilaksh2 weeks ago
    Also can you ban people who post actual trash like binary files.
    • curiousmindset2 weeks ago
      sure!

      also just added a voting feature, will add content moderation as well.

  • para_parolu2 weeks ago
    In spite of all AI hype it should give task to Davin to build it
  • FireSquid20062 weeks ago
    > uber for blowjobs
  • zer8k2 weeks ago
    1. Rewrite Rust in Git

    2. Airbnb for public benches

    3. Podcast that is only ads

    These are the ideas I want to see

  • curiousmindset1 week ago
    Update -

    Added these features -

    Voting, Infinite Scroll & Sorting ( Trending, Top Voted & Most Recent )

    Right now working on Comments, will probably ship it by tomorrow

  • MeetingsBrowser2 weeks ago
    Tried signing in with Twitter but when I clock "Authorize App" I get:

    > Something went wrong. Please make sure the data you entered is correct.

    • curiousmindset2 weeks ago
      hey, sorry for the trouble, will fix it today

      thanks for letting me know !

  • schneehertz2 weeks ago
    Interesting and useless, it's really great!
  • curiousmindset2 weeks ago
    Thanks everyone for all the suggestions and ideas so far.

    Just added a voting system based on your feedback.

    Will soon add:

    - Content moderation

    - Truncating large ideas on the UI

    - Support for markdown

  • hotpockets2 weeks ago
    need comments. but try to make it cultural that comments should be optimistic/helpful.
  • Uptrenda2 weeks ago
    You could easily turn these ideas into a poster. Get the funniest ideas and sell them as merch.
  • randomcatuser2 weeks ago
    this app is amazing
  • gjsman-10002 weeks ago
    > “A communist cosmetic surgery that takes good looking parts of faces and gives them to those in need.”

    Great idea, Hollywood first!

  • pwillia72 weeks ago
    I LOVE IT!!!!!
  • DannyBee2 weeks ago
    So the game is to add something controversial but not stupid enough to be obvious satire right?

    I went with "a captcha where you match surveillance footage to mugshots to help solve crime"

  • brettgriffin2 weeks ago
    the dating app idea seems pretty fire. hit me up if you want to work on it
  • motohagiography2 weeks ago
    maybe framing them as ideas at all is self defeating.

    What's your $0.02 insight?

  • NoZZz1 week ago
    Fart 2025
  • curiousmindset1 week ago
    comments are live !
  • ilaksh2 weeks ago
    People are flooding this with deliberately horrible ideas for some reason. I assume the reason is that people are trash. Not really what I expected from HN.
    • conductr2 weeks ago
      Curious, did you actually expect only to see billion dollar ideas?
    • anon1152 weeks ago
      one person can post several ideas with no limits....
  • randomcatuser2 weeks ago
    yeah can you make this better?

    1) show first 100 words of the idea (click into it) 2) votes! so we can see which ones are the best 3) ...thanks :))

    • curiousmindset2 weeks ago
      glad you liked it !

      and thanks for the suggestions, just added the voting feature, will add character limits as well

  • romanobro562 weeks ago
    Thank you for the reminder of how awesome the internet is lollll
  • alexander20022 weeks ago
    Most ideas are about sex HN should release a new update for rfs to include sexo /s
  • giantg22 weeks ago
    Mine are dead. They're all dead. My ideas are useless.
    • ethbr12 weeks ago
      Imagine if there were an app where you ideas could not die...
      • mindcrime2 weeks ago
        That is not dead which can eternal lie, And with strange aeons even death may die...
      • giantg22 weeks ago
        ...Then it'd be full of garbage